2004 Selections

I Sailed With Magellan — Stuart Dybek
Prisoners of War — Yarbrough
Divining Women — Kaye Gibbons
Truth & Beauty — Ann Patchett
True North — Jim Harrison
You Remind Me of Me—Dan Chaon
Port Mungo — Patrick McGrath
Eventide — Kent Haruf
Little Scarlet — Walter Mosley
Waiting for Teddy Williams — Howard Frank Mosher
Jonathan Strange & Mister Norrell — Susanna Clarke
About Grace — Anthony Doerr
Men and Cartoons — Jonathan Lethem
The Divine Husband — Francisco Goldman
The Green Age of Asher Witherow — M. Allen Cunningham
An Unfinished Life — Mark Spragg (Bonus Selection)

2005 Selections

The Celestial Jukebox — Cynthia Shearer
Baker Towers — Jennifer Haigh
Johnny Too Bad — John Dufresne
Life Studies — Susan Vreeland
Metropolis — Elizabeth Gaffney
Drama City — George Pelecanos
Gods in Alabama — Joshilyn Jackson
The Diezmo — Rick Bass
History of Love — Nicole Krauss
Glad News of the Natural World — T. R. Pearson
Canaan's Tongue — John Wray
In the Shadows of the Sun — Alexander Parsons
An Atomic Romance — Bobbie Ann Mason
Widow of the South — Robert Hicks
If You Want Me to Stay — Michael Parker
King of Kings County — Whitney Terrell
Out of Season — Robert Bausch
The Tender Bar — J. R. Moehringer
Whale Season — N. M. Kelby

2006 Selections

The Life All Around Me by Ellen Foster — Kaye Gibbons
The Brief History of the Dead — Kevin Brockmeier
The People's Act of Love — James Meek
Eat Pray Love — Elizabeth Gilbert
The Lightning Keeper — Starling Lawrence
The World Made Straight — Ron Rash
The Amalgamation Polka — Stephen Wright
A Death in Belmont — Sebastian Junger
Salvation Blues — Rodney Jones
Smonk — Tom Franklin
Coronado — Dennis Lehane
Winter's Bone — Daniel Woodrell
All Aunt Hagar's Children — Edward P. Jones
St. Lucy's Home for Girls Raised by Wolves — Karen Russell
Thirteen Moons — Charles Frazier
The Lay of the Land — Richard Ford
Thanksgiving Night — Richard Bausch
On Agate Hill — Lee Smith

2007 Selections

The Pirate’s Daughter by Margaret Cezair-Thompson
Holiday Season by Michael Knight
Run by Ann Patchett
The Used World by Haven Kimmel
Red Rover by Dierdre McNamer
Letter From Point Clear by Dennis McFarland
Mr. Sebastian and the Negro Magician by Daniel Wallace
The River Wife by Jonis Agee
Landsman by Peter Charles Melman
High Cotton by Gerald Helferich
The Ministry of Special Cases by Nathan Englander
What You Have Left by Will Allison
The Unknown Terrorist by Richard Flanagan
Coal Black Horse by Robert Olmstead
Finn by Jon Clinch
The Friends of Meager Fortune by David Adams
Richards Returning to Earth by Jim Harrison
Prime Green by Robert Stone
Trail of Crumbs by Kim Sunee (Bonus Selection)